| Week | First Star | Second Star | Third Star |
| 1 | Nathan Dann, RLM | Max Roby, DID | Larry Flett, KEN |
| 2 | Carter Poddubny, KRW | Daxton Lang, KRW | Tyler Jordan, TBN |
| 3 | Payton Hu, DID | Emmanuel Nkombou, DID | Carson Devine, DID |
| SEPTEMBER 2024 | Emmanuel Nkombou, DID | Payton Hu, DID | Tyler Jordan, TBN |
| 4 | Ashton Sadauskas, KRW | Alex Remenda, TBN | Evan Kabel, FFL |
| 5 | Nolan Fowler, ILJ | Marshall Thomas, ILJ | Kelby Diehl, DID |
| 6 | Marcellus Francis, TBN | McLaren Paulsen, DID | Jett Mintenko, KRW |
| 7 | Max Roby, DID | Daxton Lang, KRW | Jordan Wales, DID |
| OCTOBER 2024 | McLaren Paulsen, DID | Ben Laurette, TBN | Jett Mintenko, KRW |
| 8 | Eli Antoine, DID | Carson Devine, DID | Kaden Veller, SLB |
| 9 | Daxton Lang, KRW | Alex Lucas, SLB | Tait Howell, SLB |
| 10 | Gunner Paradis, FFL | Pierce Gouin, FFL | Nathan Dann, RLM |
| 11 | Aidan Charron, ILJ | Alex Lucas, SLB | Kellan Mooney, DID |
| 12 | Brady Krentz, FFL | Daxton Lang, KRW | Ian Ness, FFL |
| NOVEMBER 2024 | Alex Lucas, SLB | Daxton Lang, KRW | Brady Krentz, FFL |
| 13 | Ashton Sadauskas, KRW | Trent Boryszczuk, ILJ | Gunner Paradis, FFL |
| 14 | Jett Mintenko, KRW | Daxton Lang, KRW | Kaden Goodwin, KRW |
| 15 | Max Roby, DID | Aidan Charron, ILJ | Rylan Oatman, DID |
| DECEMBER 2024 | Daxton Lang, KRW | Gunner Paradis, FFL | Jett Mintenko, KRW |
| 16 | Kaden Goodwin, KRW | Rylan Oatman, DID | Ashton Sadauskas, KRW |
